Grant Proposal: CoW DAO Dune Governance Dashboard

[c3rnst]

Hey, remaining notes in Bulk:

Delegation Dashboard:

CoW DAO - Delegates

• You show 9 recognised delegates - we have 16 Recognised Delegates Scheme

→ Which ones are not shown? Please can you add?

In “Delegate VotesCoW DAO - Votes by Delegate”

• Can you please add if there are pending proposals and IF the delegate has already voted - this is particularly important to see if a delegator would want to override their vote (ideally with your emoji for “in voting/active”)

Active Delegations

• How do you define this?
• Maybe we can say “Current Delegators”?
• I am unsure if we want to keep it in the end for privacy reasons (I know it’s public and it’s great to check the correctness of the queries - I’ll think about it)

Delegations HistoryCoW DAO - Delegator Breakdown

• I think here it only shows the current delegation? Let’s not over-complicate, I think it’s Fine to just show the current delegation (unless previous delegations are easy to add). If you don’t add the past, maybe we can rename to “Active delegation set”?

Lastly: I’m missing a very simply chart how delegated tokens increased over time (without necessarily comparing to “circulating supply” - why? I want to see the success of the delegation program.

CoW Grants Dashboard:

• Could you also add the active in voting overview?

Main Governance dashboard:

• # ProposalsCoW DAO Proposals - Says 64 proposals, though we’re at 63?
• Kind of missing a detailed voting overview by proposal → like this on Snapshot https://snapshot.box/#/s:cow.eth/proposal/0xbafee087f3a1d5757e44a72fa76e8624ce212623153816a936a8888741485ef5/votes
• Could you switch the sections around and first do “Delegations” and then “Voting Activity”
• Note on Circulating supply:
  *

“Replicated Coingecko and CoW logic for Circulating Supply - took all minted tokens and subtracted CoW DAO, Gnosis DAO, and vested tokens.”

* Vested and unvested tokens can vote.
* CoW DAO subtraction is good
* Gnosis DAO could vote.

• Let me get back to you on this one, but I think it should be different for voting. Circulating supply for voting purposes should (in my opinion), be taken from the entire possible voting amounts (vCOW and COW), disregarding different chains etc, so basically everything that’s not kept in the CoW DAO wallet?

• Voting Power Distribution - CoW Voting Power

  • I don’t think this query is correct.
  • Firstly, could we here have the same input, but in a table (address + voting power)?
  • Many of the high-COW wallets are missing, eg. 0xca07EaA4253638D286caD71CBcEec11803F2709A or 0xa86f66e703cf776eaf4570d0a1ddb1ca0f471e82

• Not sure how I read the Gini coefficient, do you have an explanation to add in the header?

• Delegation sections:

  • Delegated TokensCoW Circulating Supply
    • I think here you just mean “Delegated Tokens”?
  • Delegated PercentageCoW Circulating Supply
    • Delegated percentage of total COW circulating supply?
  • Active DelegationsCoW Active Delegations
    • How is this defined?
    • “Number of current Delegators”?